Mar 24th 2008 2:02AM My dog hates those doggy mints, and I hate that they're so expensive, so I will definitely be trying the spearmint water for fresh breath. And, as much as I love giving my dog treats, they're not good for him. I'd much rather give him peanut butter flavored water as a treat. Also, I think it's unfair to call this product a scheme, unless you think it purports to do something it doesn't. The reason any company makes a product is to make a profit.