Five star butter? Yes, even butter can be gourmet. "The Best Butter on Earth," produced by Five Star Butter Co., claims to be the best butter on earth (imagine that!). Founded in 1999, Five Star Butter Co. was born out of one man's medical need for raw butter and cream that then slowly grew into many people's personal preference for raw butter and cream. Five Star Butter Co. previously only sold to gourmet kitchens and restaurant chefs, but now their high-end butter is available for home delivery. 83% butterfat, raw, organic cultured butter $49.95.