I'm taking another look at this one because when I first wrote about it last May there were no inside pictures for the listing. Searles Castle in Great Barrington, Massachusetts has 40 rooms and seven turrets. The home, which has most recently served as a private school is now up for sale for $15 million. The castle, which is on 61 acres, has a fascinating history, it is one of two in the New England region (the other is in New Hampshire) that bear the name of Edward Searles. Mary Hopkins, the widow of railroad tycoon Mark Hopkins commissioned the castle which was built in 1888. She hired interior decorator Edward Searles for the project, and they married a year before it was finished (she was 22 years older than he). After she died he stayed in the castle for a time and then after his death it has been a private private school, conference center among other businesses and was most recently the John Dewey Academy. The castle has 36 fireplaces, a dungeon, and more than 50 rooms for a total of around 60,000 square feet. The finishes here are amazing imported marble, accentuated fireplaces, carved wood ceilings, a Louis XIV drawing room with details in gold and original painted ceiling, music room with 42-ft dome ceiling, a slate roof, hipped and conical roofs accentuated by finials, chimneys, gablets and turrets. It's been sitting on the market since last May for $15 million.
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
2-06-2008 @ 2:20PM
Spectacular Bid said...
As a would-be private residence it will continue to languish for years to come on the market. While the Berkshires aren't physically that far away from Boston or NY it is a whole other world in terms of attracting uber wealthy people compelled to own show places.
The highest sale ever in Berkshire Co. Mass was recorded 1/07 for Southmayd Farm at $6.9 million. It was fully restored, very lovely, a semi-Gilded Age estate (although not a Berkshire Cottage of note) and acquired by low-key owners who sought a place with ample lands affording privacy. The estate is tucked deep inside the lands and very few people knew of it prior to it being marketed for sale. It took over 3 years to sell it and several price reductions.
The Sloane/Vanderbilt estate of Elm Court (only partially restored) was pitched originally at $22M while operating as an Inn and drifted in price down into the upper teens. It failed to sell despite an initial agreement with a FL hotel company. It still is a premium B&B/wedding site.
Another stone castle which operates as an Inn and Spa (Mepal Manor in New Marlboro, MA) is for sale but with very limited adertising and marketing. The asking price has been around the $6M mark with no takers.
For years now the former DeSisto School (Bonnie Brier Farm) has been for sale for a few years and under contract for over 16 months. 250+ acres, massive gilded age mansion, right near Tanglewood, perfect location and pitched for $4.5 million. It likely will be sold as a future resort but I suspect at or under $4M.
My point is that while $15M might be 'cheap' in other areas and despite there being deep pocketed residents and vistors plus the beauty of the Berkshires for some reason it just isn't translating into mega trophy purchases.
Reply
2-06-2008 @ 4:45PM
C.K. Dexter-Haven said...
Hi Spec,
Update...according to the realtors site for the Bonnie Brier Farm, it is under contract now...
Good to see your analysis again...always right on target.
2-07-2008 @ 7:11AM
artifex said...
"Was" the John Dewey Academy?
Odd, their website still lists them as being located at that site, with the castle prominently featured. And they sent out a press release as recently as last month trumpeting the acceptance rate of their 2007-2008 class into colleges. So are they still operating there until a new owner can be found?
Also, since it's an academy for troubled teens, will there be unmatriculated ghosts wandering the grounds?
Reply
2-07-2008 @ 8:09AM
KG said...
The reason the Searles Castle has been on the market so long, is because it was under contract from July until recently. There has been a tremendous amount of interest in the property, esp from foreign buyers. I dont anticipate it being available much longer.
Reply
2-07-2008 @ 1:20PM
Spectacular Bid said...
Being under contract for 6 months plus and then falling through tends to suggest the would-be buyers didn't have the money to complete the purchase or they uncovered during due diligence "problems". Would it not?
Such has been the case with the aforementioned ex-DeSisto School property (Bonnie Brier) which also had been a school for troubled youths. The would-be buyers looking to make it a polo resort uncovered oil tanks that had been leaking also financing of the project ran into issues.
Not to suggest such was the case here with Searles, but there are plenty of people out there who haven't a cent yetlike to pretend they can buy a lot of multimillion dollar homes.
While foreign buyers may be snapping up US trophy properties I doubt this will be sold as quickly as optimist "KG" suggests. I reiterate again that if sold at $15M it would be almost double the highest sale ever in that county.
Dexter how is life going on the Main Line. Almost 1 year later and I see that there have been no takers yet for Ardrossan in Radnor.
Reply