The Slow Death of the Shopping Mall

When I was growing up the shopping mall was the place to hang out, but the mall is quickly becoming a relic from the 1970s and 1980s. In fact, the last enclosed shopping mall in the U.S. was built in 2006. The trend these days is for open-air shopping in a center that offers a mix of high-end national retailers, restaurants and entertainment. Instead of being devoted to shopping exclusively these centers tap into the "shopping as a lifestyle" trend that is popular with all level of consumers. It seems to be a direct reversal of the trend in the 1980s in which the strip mall centers and standalone stores found themselves suffering. At that time many retailers moved in to malls simply because that was where everyone was.
Some malls in the United States are currently in a state of decline. The first thing that happens often is that the big department store anchor closes down. This often forces the smaller stores out of business because there is less foot traffic. For stores without an exterior entrance it is particularly hard to lure shoppers in. The problem is so virulent there are even websites such as Deadmalls.com which pay homage to the fallen.
A fascinating article in the Economist also chronicles the dying mall syndrome and also mentions Rick Caruso, the man currently tearing up the streets near my home in Glendale,CA. Glendale is already home to a huge mall, the Glendale Galleria. Right next to it, Caruos is building a 16-acre development that includes a public square and apartments. Caruso has already created a similar center at The Grove in Los Angeles and is planning another in Arcadia, CA. What is particularly interesting about the article in the Economist is the comparison between Caruso and Victor Gruen, the creator of the first enclosed shopping mall in the U.S. Both were looking to create an idealized city center that would offer shopping but also a place to converge, a sort of modern town square. Gruen's enclosed malls tended to pull people of out downtown areas and into the suburban areas. Now Caruso comes in years later offering an idealized version of a city street causing people to abandon the malls. I wonder if in another 20 years the open-air shopping centers will go through the same life cycle.
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
beanspants Jan 4th 2008 5:42PM
do you mean the "last enclosed shopping mall in X state"?, because they are building an enclosed shopping malls all around me right now in texas. they build open air too, but those are less common in where the temp regularly passes 100 F degrees.
DR.VEGAS Jan 5th 2008 12:45AM
Turnberry just finished Town Square in Las Vegas.It's open air
the success of the much smaller The District leads the to believe people will shop even in 112 degree heat.Probably.
Ken Jan 5th 2008 12:49AM
Yeah...open malls are great in LA...but what about when it 10 degrees outside, blowing snow, and there is ice and slush everywhere (good portion of the nation)?
Just stand outside for 15 minutes until the shuttle bus comes!
JESSIE JAMES Jan 7th 2008 11:35AM
I WAS RAISE WITH THE DOWNTOWN AREA SHOPPING THEN THE STRIP MALLS CAME INTO BEEN...DOWNTOWN WAS GONE AS THEY STARTED TO MOVE TO THE STRIP MALL....THEN IN THE 80'S ENCLOSED MALLS STARTED THEN ALL STRIP MALL WENT DOWN HILL...LIKE IN LIFE EVERYTHING MAKE A COMPLETE CIRCLE....DOWNTOWNS N STRIP MALLS ARE ON THE WAY BACK....